“One night, we had all gone bowling. Most people left, so it was myself, Matthew, Jorge, and Dominic—three goofy, out-there guys…” said Lilly, who is rumored to be dating Monaghan. “So we’re in the middle of a parking lot in Kailua, daring each other to do things. Jorge turns to me and says, ‘I’ll give you twenty dollars if you pee in that garbage can.’ Thirty seconds later, I’ve got my pants down and my bum hanging into this garbage can, and he has to give me twenty dollars.”